Because I have a weakness for Catholic literature (though I'm Anglican), I reserved Ronald Rolheiser's book Our One Great Act of Fidelity to review. Curiosity about the Catholic position on transubstantiation was my main objective. He covers that. For him/them it's about a physical presence, something that humans tend to need, and that makes sense to me, even though I've never been aligned with a church which literally believes in this. I will say, though, that our church is very sensitive in how the elements are prepared and handled. Never in a trivial manner and never thrown away after blessed. There is something Holy about it.
And honestly, to read the Scriptures you can go either way---either the elements do change into Christ's blood and flesh, or they don't. A laboratory can't prove it, but lots of aspects of God's presence can't be proven. Can't prove the Holy Spirit lives in my soul either.
I decided after reading the book that whether a person believes in Christ's literal blood and flesh being present in Holy Communion is a personal position. If the act of receiving the Eucharist is more dear for that belief, then absolutely believe.
Rolheiser's book is a gentle writing about the Lord's Table. The importance of a regular partaking, the forgiveness and the strength it gives us to bear/live another day.
(i received this book free to review from blogging for books)
Note: I have to add a funny bit. My husband saw me reading this the other night, and asked me about it. I told him it was Roman Catholic. He paused, took a breath and said he strictly forbid me becoming a Catholic. Made me laugh. Said I had no intention of doing that, not being partial to the Pope, etc., and told him I was completely satisfied where I am as an Anglican. Still, cracked me up. I actually think he was serious.
Note: I have to add a funny bit. My husband saw me reading this the other night, and asked me about it. I told him it was Roman Catholic. He paused, took a breath and said he strictly forbid me becoming a Catholic. Made me laugh. Said I had no intention of doing that, not being partial to the Pope, etc., and told him I was completely satisfied where I am as an Anglican. Still, cracked me up. I actually think he was serious.